Swing tips, quick question
- AshbyCut
- Honorary President
- Posts: 10142
- Joined: Sun May 06, 2012 1:27 am
- 11
- Location: North Warwickshire
Re: Swing tips, quick question
In Falkus and Buller's Freshwater Fishing," by Fred Buller and Hugh Falkus (first published by Macdonald and Jane's - 1975 ... pages 418 to 420), the author's research found the first published reference to be a description of a device in the Appendix of the third edition of "Nobbs' Art of Trolling."
Apparently, Mr. Nobbes (the spelling of his name given thus in Westwood and Satchell's "Bibliotetheca Piscatoria" (pub. 1883) ) published a book entitled "The Complete Troller, or The Art of Trolling" in 1682, so could not have written the appendix in the 1805 edition. The author of the appendix is un-named, but assumed to be a Fenman, as he recommended it's use for bream in still or slow waters, and the 1805 edition was published in Norwich.
From the description given ... they drew the illustration in the page below (the best I can scan without breaking the spine of the book) :-
Apparently, Mr. Nobbes (the spelling of his name given thus in Westwood and Satchell's "Bibliotetheca Piscatoria" (pub. 1883) ) published a book entitled "The Complete Troller, or The Art of Trolling" in 1682, so could not have written the appendix in the 1805 edition. The author of the appendix is un-named, but assumed to be a Fenman, as he recommended it's use for bream in still or slow waters, and the 1805 edition was published in Norwich.
From the description given ... they drew the illustration in the page below (the best I can scan without breaking the spine of the book) :-
"Beside the water I discovered (or maybe rediscovered) the quiet. The sort of quiet that allows one to be woven into the tapestry of nature instead of merely standing next to it." Estaban.
- Silfield
- Brown Trout
- Posts: 1455
- Joined: Mon Jan 28, 2019 8:31 pm
- 5
- Location: Norfolk
Re: Swing tips, quick question
to you for giving it a try.
I spent most of my teen years ledgering with a swing tip in all kinds of weather. On a few occasions putting a couple of turns of lead solder wire around the end to try and combat the strong wind. They can be very sensitive and I remember fondly the anticipation of watching a bite develop with your hand poised, twitching over the rod ready to strike, knowing that any clumsy knocking of the rod is going to send the swing tip dancing!
Must dig them out and have another go.
“There is certainly something in angling that tends to produce a serenity of the mind.”
Washington Irving
Washington Irving
- Pallenpool
- Zander
- Posts: 3712
- Joined: Tue Sep 06, 2016 2:04 pm
- 7
- Location: North Norfolk
Re: Swing tips, quick question
Fascinating insight - that surely is the earliest recorded use of a swing tip - of sorts.AshbyCut wrote: ↑Sun Sep 20, 2020 4:03 pm In Falkus and Buller's Freshwater Fishing," by Fred Buller and Hugh Falkus (first published by Macdonald and Jane's - 1975 ... pages 418 to 420), the author's research found the first published reference to be a description of a device in the Appendix of the third edition of "Nobbs' Art of Trolling."
Apparently, Mr. Nobbes (the spelling of his name given thus in Westwood and Satchell's "Bibliotetheca Piscatoria" (pub. 1883) ) published a book entitled "The Complete Troller, or The Art of Trolling" in 1682, so could not have written the appendix in the 1805 edition. The author of the appendix is un-named, but assumed to be a Fenman, as he recommended it's use for bream in still or slow waters, and the 1805 edition was published in Norwich.
From the description given ... they drew the illustration in the page below (the best I can scan without breaking the spine of the book) :-
No man ever steps in the same river twice, for it's not the same river and he's not the same man.
Heraclitus
www.thepiscatorialraconteurs.co.uk
Heraclitus
www.thepiscatorialraconteurs.co.uk
- Old Man River
- Eel
- Posts: 2173
- Joined: Wed Nov 25, 2015 3:43 pm
- 8
- Location: Yorkshire
Re: Swing tips, quick question
A good piece of detective work there Mal, taking the idea back from the 1960"s at least 150 years ! In fact , such an item could easily be included in a vintage "pole" setup to target fish on the bottom and hand feeding groundbait very accurately to the spot.AshbyCut wrote: ↑Sun Sep 20, 2020 4:03 pm In Falkus and Buller's Freshwater Fishing," by Fred Buller and Hugh Falkus (first published by Macdonald and Jane's - 1975 ... pages 418 to 420), the author's research found the first published reference to be a description of a device in the Appendix of the third edition of "Nobbs' Art of Trolling."
Apparently, Mr. Nobbes (the spelling of his name given thus in Westwood and Satchell's "Bibliotetheca Piscatoria" (pub. 1883) ) published a book entitled "The Complete Troller, or The Art of Trolling" in 1682, so could not have written the appendix in the 1805 edition. The author of the appendix is un-named, but assumed to be a Fenman, as he recommended it's use for bream in still or slow waters, and the 1805 edition was published in Norwich.
From the description given ... they drew the illustration in the page below (the best I can scan without breaking the spine of the book) :-
Amazing what the answers to a quick question reveal over a period of days.
OMR
Hurrumph....... whatever happened to Handlines ?
- Duckett
- Tench
- Posts: 2889
- Joined: Wed May 17, 2017 2:42 pm
- 6
- Location: Stratford E15
Re: Swing tips, quick question
That’s a wonderful bit of historical detective work Mal and unimpeachable! Many thanks. This is the sort of thread that makes me come back to TFF again and again.AshbyCut wrote: ↑Sun Sep 20, 2020 4:03 pm In Falkus and Buller's Freshwater Fishing," by Fred Buller and Hugh Falkus (first published by Macdonald and Jane's - 1975 ... pages 418 to 420), the author's research found the first published reference to be a description of a device in the Appendix of the third edition of "Nobbs' Art of Trolling."
Apparently, Mr. Nobbes (the spelling of his name given thus in Westwood and Satchell's "Bibliotetheca Piscatoria" (pub. 1883) ) published a book entitled "The Complete Troller, or The Art of Trolling" in 1682, so could not have written the appendix in the 1805 edition. The author of the appendix is un-named, but assumed to be a Fenman, as he recommended it's use for bream in still or slow waters, and the 1805 edition was published in Norwich.
From the description given ... they drew the illustration in the page below (the best I can scan without breaking the spine of the book) :-
Phil
From "... the wilds of the Wirral, whose wayward people both God and good men have quite given up on ...".
- Deaf Cat
- Grayling
- Posts: 655
- Joined: Fri Dec 09, 2011 10:59 pm
- 12
- Location: Herault, France
Re: Swing tips, quick question
I have a (glass) Hardy Swingtip 9’6” which I used to catch bream about 15 years ago in a Kent reservoir.
I also have a similar 8’9” version (can’t remember how I acquired it) which has been immaculately converted into a quiver tip. This caught me my first decent chub from the Witham just last week.
I also have a similar 8’9” version (can’t remember how I acquired it) which has been immaculately converted into a quiver tip. This caught me my first decent chub from the Witham just last week.
Duffer - The man without skill of hand, without good eyesight and no longer young - the man who really ought to fish!
(H.M. Bateman / R.D. Peck)
(H.M. Bateman / R.D. Peck)
- Moley
- Brown Trout
- Posts: 1446
- Joined: Mon Jul 16, 2012 11:57 am
- 11
- Location: The Mole Fortress, near the South Coast
- Contact:
Re: Swing tips, quick question
The Swing-Tip as we sort of know it was invented by Jack Clayton in the mid 1950's to solve a specific problem of bite detection whilst ledgering for roach. However the tip really began to be used by Match Teams from 1958 onwards when the Spalding Team started to not only use them but win matches too. The idea seemed to hit a note with the South Yorkshire/Sheffield lads with Fred Foster being particularly taken with the method. So much so he became known as The Tip King on the Witham and Welland. His influence in the Fen land matches was such that arguably he was better known than Walker et al in the North of the country and but for his premature death in 1976 from 'Coal Disease' should have become better known. His book Fred Foster's Swing Tipping, published posthumously, is a Bible for this style of fishing and a must read.
Whilst this Fatty applauds Ashby Cut's research and consequently Falkus and Buller's work establishing a rope bite indicating device from 1805 whilst trolling for game fish perhaps it might be taking things a little far to compare the set ups and useage. Let's face it, Trolling for game fish using a rope indicator in some Scottish Loch system is just not the same in any way, shape or form, to ledgering in the flat, windswept Fens for roach and bream, is it?
Kevin Ashurst stated baldly that to deny Jack Clayton as the inventor of the Swing Tip by quoting from obscure historical sources 'should have done us all a favour if they had drawn our attention to it before Jack did. Since they did not it must be assumed that they did not understand what had been written until Jack's genius began to revolutionize the sport of angling.'
By the by Jack Clayton could not afford to patent his designs, so consequently made very little money from the invention that took a fishing technique regarded by many as 'semi-legitimate eel splodging' to another level and became the way to catch shy biting fish to the present day!
Hopefully this missive will explain some common misconceptions with regard to the Swing-Tip
And yes I am that bloody old to remember the above.
As ever,.....
Moley
Whilst this Fatty applauds Ashby Cut's research and consequently Falkus and Buller's work establishing a rope bite indicating device from 1805 whilst trolling for game fish perhaps it might be taking things a little far to compare the set ups and useage. Let's face it, Trolling for game fish using a rope indicator in some Scottish Loch system is just not the same in any way, shape or form, to ledgering in the flat, windswept Fens for roach and bream, is it?
Kevin Ashurst stated baldly that to deny Jack Clayton as the inventor of the Swing Tip by quoting from obscure historical sources 'should have done us all a favour if they had drawn our attention to it before Jack did. Since they did not it must be assumed that they did not understand what had been written until Jack's genius began to revolutionize the sport of angling.'
By the by Jack Clayton could not afford to patent his designs, so consequently made very little money from the invention that took a fishing technique regarded by many as 'semi-legitimate eel splodging' to another level and became the way to catch shy biting fish to the present day!
Hopefully this missive will explain some common misconceptions with regard to the Swing-Tip
And yes I am that bloody old to remember the above.
As ever,.....
Moley
Say aye tae'a pie!
- Dave Burr
- Honorary Vice President
- Posts: 13508
- Joined: Fri Jul 20, 2012 7:03 pm
- 11
- Location: Not far from the Wye
- Contact:
Re: Swing tips, quick question
Great work Mal and a very decent counter from our pie munching friend.
Personally, my best day's 'swing tipping' came when I bought a Spring Tip but that's for another day.
Personally, my best day's 'swing tipping' came when I bought a Spring Tip but that's for another day.
- Old Man River
- Eel
- Posts: 2173
- Joined: Wed Nov 25, 2015 3:43 pm
- 8
- Location: Yorkshire
Re: Swing tips, quick question
I think, Moley, that you may have slightly misunderstood Ashby cuts contribution.
The piece was brought to light, as I read it, in a section or appendix to the larger piece about trolling, the appendix being written in the early 1800’s, and not actually concerning itself with trolling in any form, but merely offering some other interesting information on a different subject.
I dont think anybody would , even in the mists of time consider trolling as a logical way of catching bream, as Mal says the inference is that the appendix comes from the the Fens being published in Norwich , where lets face it, bream are or were somewhat plentiful.
To me the piece makes sense, and should not be thought of as anything to do with “ trolling” , that being just the “ vehicle” that carried the later information .
Having said the above, I am not arguing with the more recent ( early 50’s onwards ) history Moley provides ,as I had scant knowledge of it myself, and all contributions here are very interesting.
OMR
The piece was brought to light, as I read it, in a section or appendix to the larger piece about trolling, the appendix being written in the early 1800’s, and not actually concerning itself with trolling in any form, but merely offering some other interesting information on a different subject.
I dont think anybody would , even in the mists of time consider trolling as a logical way of catching bream, as Mal says the inference is that the appendix comes from the the Fens being published in Norwich , where lets face it, bream are or were somewhat plentiful.
To me the piece makes sense, and should not be thought of as anything to do with “ trolling” , that being just the “ vehicle” that carried the later information .
Having said the above, I am not arguing with the more recent ( early 50’s onwards ) history Moley provides ,as I had scant knowledge of it myself, and all contributions here are very interesting.
OMR
Hurrumph....... whatever happened to Handlines ?
- Moley
- Brown Trout
- Posts: 1446
- Joined: Mon Jul 16, 2012 11:57 am
- 11
- Location: The Mole Fortress, near the South Coast
- Contact:
Re: Swing tips, quick question
Well really the swing 'tip' was invented by Jesus when he told the lake Nazareth fishers to swing their nets to the other side of the boat in the new Testament book of Matthew and lo their nets were full. If that is not a swing 'tip' I don't know what is........so any advance on 2000 years then?
No doubt there is a case for the stick and bone hook being a type of swing tip as the stick, placed in the ground and pointing skywards indicated a bite. This style of fishing is still practised at Cromwell Weir, for barbel, but dates back to the dawn of time.
Nowt new in fishing!
As ever,......
Moley
No doubt there is a case for the stick and bone hook being a type of swing tip as the stick, placed in the ground and pointing skywards indicated a bite. This style of fishing is still practised at Cromwell Weir, for barbel, but dates back to the dawn of time.
Nowt new in fishing!
As ever,......
Moley
Say aye tae'a pie!